Feast of the Resurrection, C, April 20, 2025
I remember being in school
and having to do all my math by hand,
showing all my work.
Of course, the reasoning always given
for solving these problems long hand
was “You won’t always have a calculator!”
Well,
I guess we showed them, huh?!
I have a calculator,
a compass, a phone, a notebook,
a camera, a calendar, a measuring tape, a level,
the whole Bible, Luther’s Small Catechism,
a parking meter, a newspaper, all my favorite music,
a tv, and the entire internet
in my pocket.
All day.
Every day.
And it has completely changed our lives.
Often for the better.
This thing can summon an Uber if you’re stranded.
It can order takeout if you burn dinner.
It can remind you
it’s time for your pet’s flea and tick medication.
It can help you run a small business out of your home.
It can help you stay in touch with friends and family
who live far away.
It can guide you, turn-by-turn, from one destination to the next.
It can help you find and connect to a community.
It can help you pray.
But,
as they say,
the greater the light,
the greater the shadow.
For all the good these devices can do,
they are also capable of inflicting great pain.
There is a show on MTV called Catfish.
The premise of the show
is that people write into the host
for help in tracking down
a person they met online.
Usually,
the person who writes in
has met someone
on social media or a dating site,
and they have formed a relationship.
The person writing in is usually deeply in love
and, because their significant other
has failed or refused to video chat
or meet in person,
the subject of the show has become suspicious
that the other person has not been truthful
about their identity or some aspect of their lives,
and they want the host of the show
to help them get to the bottom of the situation.
With very rare exceptions,
the show almost always ends
with one person devastated
at the loss of this relationship
and embarrassed
at having been duped,
while the other person is exposed and ashamed.
Further,
the internet has made it easier
for hate groups to organize,
created a platform for fringe conspiracy theorists
to gather a following,
and allowed our politicians
to circumvent the normal means of mass communication,
replacing press conferences
and nuanced policy discussions
with tweets and hashtags,
memes and TikTok videos.
Despite the fact
that the internet and smart phones
have democratized
access to information
we have only built higher walls between us
and allowed pundits and politicians
to divide us
and pit us against one another.
Ultimately,
we all wind up echoing the question of Pontius Pilate
from the Gospel of John:
“What is truth?”
It has become very difficult
to know the truth
and to trust it.
We are all fearful
that we are living in some cosmic version
of an episode of Catfish,
being gaslit by our virtual relationship to reality
and hoping that someone will be able
to help us find what is real.
And then we come here this Easter morning
with all our grief, suspicion, and anxiety
to hear a story about a man rising from the dead
and it feels like a bridge too far.
Like some sort of fable
or children’s story,
the stuff of legend
or naivete,
and we are too grown up,
too educated, too streetwise
or too wounded
to fall for it.
To be quite honest,
just reading these lessons for this Feast day,
it sure seems like even the people in the texts themselves
struggled to believe what they were hearing.
If we zoom out
to the whole of the 10th chapter of Acts,
Peter has received a vision
of “unclean” animals—
or non-kosher animals—
and a voice says that he should
“Rise, kill, and eat.”
Peter is a good Jewish boy,
and he is suspicious,
like this is a test of some sort,
and he says to the voice,
“Yeah, no thanks.”
The vision repeats itself twice more
and he repeats his answer both times.
Then a group of visitors arrives
and asks Peter to come to the home of Cornelius,
a Roman centurion of the Italian Cohort,
because Gentile Cornelius and his non-kosher household
what to be baptized into the church.
Then Peter gets it,
and our first reading is his response.
Paul gives a lovely defense
of belief in the resurrection in our second reading,
but you’ll remember that
had he not been knocked off his horse
on the road to Damascus
or he would have still been persecuting Christians
instead of being one.
And by his own account,
even after that miraculous experience,
he still spent 14 years learning what it all meant
before he became the Apostle to the Gentiles.
And then the Gospel reading.
These women are standing in the empty tomb,
and had it not been for these shiny-clothed messengers
they wouldn’t understood what was happening.
And when they tell the story to the apostles,
they don’t believe either.
Peter has to get up
and go to the tomb to see for himself.
If these women can stand in the empty tomb
and not get it;
if Paul had to be struck down
and re-educated;
if Peter had to be told multiple times
and has to go stand in the empty tomb himself—
what hope is there for us
who struggle to know the truth,
who are suspicious of being duped,
who are leery of being catfished by reality?
Well,
our hope
is precisely in their disbelief,
incredulity,
and hesitation.
Peter wasn’t convinced by the threefold vision.
Or by the women’s story.
Paul wasn’t convinced by the blinding light
or the voice of Jesus.
The women weren’t convinced
by standing in the empty tomb.
In each instance,
they needed reminding,
repetition,
contextualization.
They needed some time
to become acquainted
with this new version of reality.
Their experience needed a story,
and the story needed their experience.
The Resurrection of Jesus
is not an idle tale to be believed
in spite of our better judgement,
but a reintroduction to reality—
a reality that includes the brutality of the cross,
the suffering of grief,
the ubiquity of death,
the tyranny of empire,
the injustice and oppression of state violence,
the skepticism of disbelief,
and transcends all of it
with awe and wonder,
with healing and hope,
with life, freedom, and justice,
with a resilience we might call faith.
The story of the Resurrection
is not a fairy tale ending
to the narrative of the life and death of Jesus.
The story of the Resurrection
is not some creedal litmus test,
is not a Pollyanna hope in the afterlife
that abandons us to the whims and wiles of this one.
The Resurrection of Jesus
is a story looking for your experience.
The Resurrection of Jesus
is an invitation to trust
that suffering, grief, death,
tyranny, injustice, and oppression
are not final.
The Resurrection is less about belief
and far more about experience,
about discovering that life and death and resurrection
are always happening.
The Resurrection is about showing up
to grieve what we have lost
and finding that God was working
while we weren’t looking,
in ways we could not have guessed,
in ways we cannot quite understand.
The Resurrection
is about standing in the empty grave
of all our hopes and dreams
and needing to be reminded that God promised
to bring life out of death.
The Resurrection
is about holding space for our disbelief
until our experience makes sense of the story.
The Resurrection
is about trusting our experience
when the story is hard to believe
and trusting the story
when our experience is hard to bear.
This practiced trust
builds in us a resilience
we might just call faith.
And seeing it for ourselves,
we will go on our way,
amazed at what has happened.
Christ is risen indeed! Alleluia!
Amen.









